Kristin Shetler Real Estate Team

Real Estate Agent
License# RS320710

24 S MAIN STREET, Shrewsbury, PA 17361

 (Sold on )

$499,000

  • Open House
  • New Listing
  • Price Reduced
  • Active
-1 More Schedule
  • 4 BedroomBeds
  • 5 BathroomBaths
  • 4,014Sqft
  • 0Acres
  • Single FamilyType
  • PAYK2111806MLS#
-1 More Schedule

Property Description

Welcome to 24 S Main Streetthe house hack opportunity youve been waiting for! Move in to one unit while collecting rents on the other units-those units can pay your mortgage! Your next adventure awaits. This 3 unit multi-family home is nestled along historic S. Main Street on arguably the most charming street in Shrewsbury. This home has been lovingly maintained and thoughtfully updated combining historic character, flexible living space, and investment potential. With three separate residential units, a detached studio apartment, and two detached garage spaces, this property offers countless possibilities for an owner-occupant, multi-generational living arrangement, or savvy investor. We love our tenants and we do not want to disturb them unnecessarily unless we have to! Pre-Approvals required for showings. Unit 1 referred to as 24 FRONT features 1 bedroom, 1 full bath, and 1 half bath. Unit 2 referred to as 24 BACK offers 2 bedrooms, 1 full bath, 1 half bath, plus a flexible office space that could potentially serve as a third bedroom. Unit 3 referred to as Unit 22 features 1 bedroom and 1 full bath. Then there is a separate detached studio apartment with its own full bath, kitchenette, and bedroom. The sellers have poured their heart and soul into this property, completing numerous updates while preserving the character that makes this home so special. Improvements include updated bathrooms, brand-new mini-split systems, new lighting, fresh paint, LVP flooring in select areas, (they purposefully maintained original hardwood flooring in some places), a washer and dryer in each unit, recently pressure-washed and painted exterior, new shutters, and new planter boxes. The property also offers a lovely, long shared backyardan inviting place to relax, garden, entertain, or simply enjoy the outdoors. This part of Shrewsbury in the cutest! The town has homespun, laid-back vibes, while still having easy and convenient access to I-83. (20 minutes north is York PA, and 20 minutes south is Hunt Valley, MD). Walmart and Saubel's are both conveniently close for everyday shopping and groceries. Shrewsbury has a great community atmosphere with cute hometown parades and the like. Take a stroll to The Village Coffee & Ice Cream four doors down which is housed in what used to be the towns bank. This is the perfect example of the unique character and small-town charm that surrounds this property. Sellers have NEVER had trouble renting any of the units. There is just too much good about the property. With multiple existing units, separate laundry, updated mechanical systems, a detached studio, garage space, and a desirable location, there is tremendous flexibility here. The sellers do not have to sell and have cared for this property with genuine pride and affection. They would simply love to see it go to the right buyer who will appreciate its history, charm, and incredible potential. If you've been looking for a property that offers both a place to call home and an opportunity to build wealth through real estate, this one deserves a closer look.

Property Videos And Tours

Additional Virtual Tour

Property Details 24 S MAIN STREET, SHREWSBURY, PA 17361

Facts & Features

  • MLS #: PAYK2111806
  • Status: Active
  • Date Listed: 09/23/2026
  • Type: Single Family
  • Year Built: 1800
  • Style: Colonial
  • Price: $499,000
  • Acres: 0.19
  • Area: Shrewsbury Boro (15284)
  • County: York
  • Bedrooms: 4
  • Bathrooms: 5
  • Full Baths: 3
  • Half Baths: 2
  • Total SqFt: 4,014

Amenities

  • # of Garages: 2
  • Waterfront Type: Public

Interior

  • Appliances: Built-In Range, Range Hood, Refrigerator
  • Heating: Hot Water
  • Cooling: Central A/C
  • Basement: Yes

Exterior

  • Construction: Brick

Schools

  • School District: Southern York County
  • Elementary: Shrewsbury
  • Middle: Southern
  • High: Susquehannock

Additional Information

  • Zoning: Village Center

Tax Information

  • Tax: $5,600

Output format
 

Estimated Monthly Mortgage Calculator

This calculator is provided for informational purposes only by Burrow Services, Inc. You should not make any decisions based simply on the information provided. Values indicated are estimates and may not be accurate and are only to be used as a guide. This calculator should not be relied upon in any way as the sole source of information. Please consult your financial, tax or legal advisers for an accurate assessment of your mortgage payments and any advice relating to your personal circumstances.

Similar Listings